Ranking the 4 MTG Star Trek Precon Commander Decks: Best to Worst

Not all four Magic: The Gathering Star Trek Commander decks offer the same experience. Some provide straightforward strategies with valuable reprints, while others reward experienced players who enjoy complicated interactions and building powerful combinations.

To create this ranking, we considered gameplay strategy, ease of learning, reprint value, and upgrade potential. Whether you're buying your first Commander deck or adding another to your collection, here's how the four Star Trek decks stack up ahead of their November 13, 2026 release.

Affiliate Disclosure: Thornberry Collectibles participates in affiliate programs, including TCGplayer and Amazon Associates. If you purchase products through affiliate links on this page, we may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you. These commissions help support our website and allow us to continue creating free collector guides, checklists, and trading card content.

Best MTG Star Trek Precon Commander Decks at a Glance

1. Landing Party - Best Overall

Landing Party earns our top spot among the Best MTG Star Trek Precon Commander Decks because it offers the strongest combination of a reliable Commander strategy, valuable reprints, and long-term upgrade potential. Led by Commander Spock, the deck rewards players for controlling differently named lands, allowing them to generate card advantage and potentially cast spells for free.

That strategy works particularly well with the deck's established landfall cards. Exploration helps players develop their mana faster, while Ancient Greenwarden and Lotus Cobra provide additional rewards for playing lands. It's a familiar approach that can generate powerful advantages without requiring an elaborate combination of cards.

Landing Party also has the highest estimated reprint value of the four decks. Cards like Exploration, Sea of Clouds, and Heroic Intervention offer considerable utility beyond the Star Trek theme, making this an attractive purchase even for players who eventually dismantle the deck for other Commander projects.

The biggest criticism is that Landing Party relies heavily on familiar land-based mechanics rather than introducing an entirely new playstyle. However, that's also part of its appeal. Players get a recognizable strategy that's relatively easy to understand, with plenty of opportunities to upgrade as their collections grow.

2. We Are the Borg - Best Artifact Synergies

We Are the Borg takes second place with one of the most interesting strategies in the lineup. The Borg Queen leads an artifact-creature deck built around creating Borg tokens, assimilating opposing creatures, and turning those creatures into a powerful collective.

The deck's individual cards support that strategy particularly well. Join the Collective can clear opposing creatures while helping rebuild your battlefield with Borg tokens, while Unwinding Clock provides additional utility for an artifact-heavy deck.

Its estimated $120.76 in reprint value also gives players useful cards beyond the new Star Trek designs, including Morphic Pool and Academy Ruins.

The biggest drawback is its higher learning curve. The Borg Queen costs seven mana, and players need to understand how the deck's artifact interactions work together to get the most from it. For experienced Commander players, however, We Are the Borg could be even more entertaining than Landing Party.

3. Klingon Fury - Best Aggressive Deck

Klingon Fury rewards players who prefer attacking opponents rather than waiting to assemble complicated combinations. Led by Worf, Defiant Commander, the deck encourages aggressive multiplayer combat and rewards players for spreading their attacks across the table.

Cards like Combat Celebrant and Shared Animosity give the deck ways to increase its offensive pressure, while Sword of Light and Shadow adds another valuable reprint. Players can also experiment with Kor, Cause of Vengeance as an alternative commander for a more sacrifice-focused strategy.

Klingon Fury finishes third because aggressive strategies can struggle against opponents who consistently remove creatures or establish strong defenses. Still, its straightforward game plan and estimated $97.47 in reprints make it an appealing option for combat-focused players.

4. Federation Fleet - Best for Legendary Creatures

Federation Fleet takes fourth place with a strategy built around legendary characters, card advantage, and Spacecraft. Led by Jean-Luc Picard, Luminary, the deck rewards players for assembling recognizable Star Trek characters and using their abilities together.

Despite its name, Federation Fleet includes only five Spacecraft, which may disappoint players expecting a deck built primarily around starships. However, Captain Janeway, Endgame offers an alternative commander for players who prefer a more aggressive strategy involving Officer tokens.

The deck includes useful reprints such as Cryptic Command and Supreme Verdict, although its estimated $83.75 reprint value is the lowest of the four.

Federation Fleet finishes fourth because its strategy appears less immediately focused than the higher-ranked options. That doesn't make it a bad deck, particularly for Star Trek fans who enjoy legendary creatures and experimenting with different combinations.

Final Rankings: Which Star Trek Commander Deck Wins?

For most players, Landing Party is our top recommendation. It offers the best combination of accessible gameplay, valuable reprints, and long-term upgrade potential, making it the safest overall purchase.

Magic: The Gathering | Star Trek Play Booster Box

We Are the Borg is a close second for players who prefer more complicated artifact synergies, while Klingon Fury is a strong choice for aggressive multiplayer games. Federation Fleet rounds out the lineup with a flexible legendary-creature strategy that should particularly appeal to longtime Star Trek fans.

All four regular Commander decks are scheduled for November 13, 2026, although Wizards has warned that North American shipments may experience delays.

These rankings are based on the official decklists, card value, and expected gameplay rather than hands-on testing. Each deck offers a different experience, and the best choice ultimately depends on how you enjoy playing Commander.